
|
NEWSLETTER No.4 |
Message from Adridharana Dasa,
Temple President ISKCON Calcutta:Welcome to our 4th
newsletter. In this issue, we will again cover many topics, but in particular we
will expose the absurdity of a Guru system that functions not via
'physical contact with the Guru', but rather via instructions delivered in the
main, from Srila Prabhupada. Thus on the one hand we are told that Srila
Prabhupada cannot be our diksa guru because we need a 'physically present' Guru.
Yet the 'physically present' Guru now tells us that he does not need to be
'physically present' to instruct his disciples, since Srila Prabhupada can
instruct them via his books!!
|
Contents: |
|
1. Poison Theorists Accuse Adri of Complicity |
It seems that the poison theorists have now even accused myself of being involved, as the following posting from VNN shows:
"Why
did Adri-dharana not follow up his knowledge of SP poisoning. [...]I know
I'm walking on thin ice! But why all the Ritvik noise when you did nothing
about the poison issue in '77. Are you covering up for TKG?"
|
|
FACTS |
"Following
publication of the book 'Someone Has Poisoned Me', some GBC apologists have
attempted to link the poison issue with the ritvik issue. No doubt they are
banking on the 'poisoning' being debunked so that ritvik is also discredited. If
this is their hope then they will be sorely disappointed. The truth is that they
are two entirely separate issues. Anyone looking at our web-site will quickly
realise that there is not one single official IRG position paper on the poison
issue. Not one. As far as the IRG are concerned ISKCON leaders must re-instate
Srila Prabhupada's preferred initiation system regardless of whether some of
them poisoned Srila Prabhupada in 1977. Certainly such a serious allegation
needs investigation, and the GBC have commissioned Balavanta Das for this
purpose. Hopefully his investigation will provide a complete view of all the
facts and evidence. In particular, the test results for the key piece of
evidence, the arsenic in the hair, will be presented in Balavanta's report. Once
we have all the facts and evidence it might be easier to make an informed
statement on the likelihood that Srila Prabhupada was murdered. If it is decided
by the investigation that Srila Prabhupada was indeed most likely deliberately
poisoned then we may have a motive to offer the investigation; but whatever the
case, our position will not be weakened by the outcome of the investigation, and
our action against the GBC over initiations will continue unabated.
Balavanta Das
Naveen Krishna Das
Madhusevita Das (who as GBC chairman authorised Balavanta's investigation in
1997)
Mahabhuddi Das
Isa Das
Rocana Das
Puru Das etc. etc.
are all characterised by the fact that to our knowledge NONE of them agree with
the ritvik position, or are in anyway involved with the IRG.
|
2.
Indradyumna Swami Dismisses Need for Physical Presence |
The following is taken from an Indradyumna Swami 'darshan' - (Text COM:1974636). My comments are in brackets:
| "But I would offer that there is a misconception here in guru-disciple relationship. Of course, it is certainly nice if one can have some personal instruction, a personal direction in one's life from the spiritual master. But one's success in Krsna consciousness is not necessarily based on that." |
Here Maharaja very nicely sums up the IRG position - that the absence of 'personal direction' does not hinder one's spiritual life.
| "Srila Prabhupada personally interacted with his spiritual master maybe three or four occasions. I think, he wrote two letters to Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati, and received one reply. And if one's advancement in Krsna Consciousness is dependent upon the personal association of the spiritual master, directing one in one's daily activities, then what are the chances of me in perfecting my Krsna consciousness because my spiritual master passed away in 1977? I haven't seen Srila Prabhupada almost twenty years. " |
Maharaja again destroy's the GBC's current 'living Guru' idea.
| "So I think there is a fallacy, there is something wrong in this mentality, that the spiritual master is not taking proper care of his disciples if he is not able to answer each and every one of their letters. The spiritual master is not Krsna. He can't expand himself in 16,108 forms and personally be with each disciple." |
Maharaja here perfectly exposes the falsity of the need for the Guru to have a vapu form to be able to take 'proper care of his disciples'.
| "So if my disciples listen very carefully to the lectures, to the tape ministry, and read the few books that I've printed, and carefully study Srila Prabhupada's books, I feel that they are armed with knowledge to stand and fight against the material energy. I am completely, hundred percent confident of that." |
So the disciples need to take instruction primarily from Srila Prabhupada - since which Guru can compare with Srila Prabhupada's tapes and books?
| "That's the way I follow myself in my relationship with Prabhupada, my spiritual master. I had the liberty in one or two occasions to ask from Prabhupada for some personal instruction, but now, if I need to understand something, I read the books or I can solve it with my godbrothers. So then I ask the disciples to do the same." |
So the program is to read Srila Prabhupada's books, and take siksa from other senior devotees - the same formula given in 'The Final Order'.
| "But we do have the knowledge. It is available in Srila Prabhupada's books, it is available through our spiritual master's lectures through Nilakantha's tape ministry. There is a lot! There is more that comes out from this tape machine than just plastic tapes (shakes a tape). What really comes out of that tape recorder on these tapes is divya-jnana, or transcendental knowledge." |
This of course also
applies to Srila Prabhupada's tapes!
|
Conclusion |
Maharaja has given here a
perfect treatise on why the current Guru system is unnecessary. He has admitted
himself, that he is not giving any value, and instead leaving it mainly up to
Srila Prabhupada. So why not stop pretending and leave EVERYTHING to Srila
Prabhupada - including the disciples which belong to him only. We do not need
anymore of the "Let Srila Prabhupada do all the work - but let us take the
credit" mentality! Maharaja has offered ample justification for cutting out
the middle man since he wants us to take shelter directly of Srila Prabhupada
anyway
| 3. Readers' Letters |
| "I may be working in New York near the end of Sept. for a week or so. If there is anything I can do on behalf of the Manhattan Project while I'm there, please let me know. If I'm not mistaken, "The Manhattan Project" was the top secret name for the development of the Atom Bomb during WWII, which eventually put the USA in a unique position in world power. (Dravinaksa Das, USA) |
| "This is Jagat Candra Das from Cochin, just to say -" Great work Adri Prabhu ! keep at it ! " I wonder how you tolerated all those guys all these years. You must have had tremendous patience & Grit. Madhu Pandit Dasa at least did not know till recently. I feel really sad for all those who left because of these guys. But you hung on! Let me know what I can do too." (Jagat Chandra Das, India) |
| "Thank you very much for including me as a list member for your news. I just moved here to Picayune, MS (one hour north of New Orleans) near the New Talavan farm. Sri Krsna Balarama and Sri Sri Giriraja Maharaja take care of us at our home. Praghosa (ACBSP) and family live nearby. IF you come through this part of the country please give us your association by visiting. Keep up your fight, all glory to your service." (Papaharini devi dasi, USA) |
| "By the mercy of a friend of mine I received the second edition of your newsletter. Please include my e-mail in your list." (Nitya Dasa, Brazil) |
| "This is one of the best newsletters I've ever seen. Thank you for all your work. I'm always watching your progress, hoping that ISKCON soon becomes Srila Prabhupada's society again. My prayers are with you." (Bhakta Wolfgang, Austria) |
| 4. Showdown in Brooklyn |
2 weeks ago, Jayananda Das and Brahma Bhuta Das, the leaders from the Manhattan Project, accompanied by life members and other devotees went to the Sunday Feast at the New York temple in Brooklyn. Overhearing them discussing a particular ritvik devotee, one of the temple devotees immediately threatened them that they must leave the temple at once, or they would call the Police.
Jayananda simply asked
them to go ahead, since they weren't going anywhere! They were then threatened
with a ban on coming to the temple. To this the IRG devotees simply asked them
to put the ban in writing on ISKCON letterhead. Again the temple devotee backed
down, adding that they would not be so stupid to put such a ban 'on ISKCON
letterhead'. Finally another devotee came and threatened violence towards
Jayananda and the other devotees, adding that he was from the 'streets' and
ex-military. However another devotee quickly took him aside and told him that
threatening Jayananda would not be a good idea 'since Jayananda knows everyone
in the city'. Again they had to back down. Finally a raging argument broke out
with the temple devotees trying to preach against Srila Prabhupada as the Diksa
Guru of ISKCON. A big crowd formed around Jayananda and the others, while the
Indian congregation who had come to the Sunday feast looked on in amazement.
Whilst they were watching the argument, the life member who had came with
Jayananda and the other devotees went and distributed 'Final Orders' to all the
guests who were listening. The IRG devotees kept on preaching to all the temple
devotees, defeating all their arguments, well after all the guests had left. In
fact the preaching went on till 1 a.m. in the morning!
In summary, the days of
threatening and bullying dissenters, are numbered, and the ISKCON authorities
will have to face up to the fact that 'all the armies in the world, cannot stop
an idea whose time has come'. The spirit of 1966 is alive once again, as Srila
Prabhupada reconquers New York.
Thank you for taking the
time to read this newsletter, and please keep your letters, and e-mail addresses
of other devotees who should be added to our list, flowing in. A hard copy of
our main position paper 'The Final Order' is available on request. All other IRG
papers
Your comments, questions
and feedback is appreciated. Please write to me at adri@cwcom.net
Your Servant,