Did Jesus Really Die?


This page examines the New Testament evidence concerning Jesus' death.

Click here to return to Jesus Christ, the History Maker, or on any of the other topics below:


  1. Before Jesus was crucified he was flogged (Mt 27:26, Mk 15:15, Jn 19:1). The nature of a Roman flogging is well-known to historians. They used a multi-thonged whip in which were embedded various sharp objects, so that the flesh was torn from the victim's back. It was by no means unusual for victims to die from the wounds.


  2. It was normal for a man being crucified to carry his own cross to the place of execution. Apparently, they followed the same procedure for Jesus initially (Jn 19:17). But it would appear that, following his flogging Jesus was already in such a weakened state that he couldn't continue, and it is recorded that, as they led him away another man (concerning whom the writers supply not only his name, but even the names of his sons) was pressed into service (Mt 27:32, Mk 15:21, Lk 23:26).



  3. The task of crucifixion was entrusted to professional Roman soldiers (Mt 27:27-36, Mk 15:16, Lk 23:47, Jn 19:23) for whom crucifixion was a routine task, and failure to carry out such an order was punishable by death.

  4. How much would it have cost to bribe the Centurion and get Jesus down off the cross still alive?

  5. The Jewish rulers wanted to be quite sure Jesus was dead. They were present to witness the event (Mt 27:41, Mk 15:31, Lk 23:35) and even objected to the wording of Pilate's superscription on the cross (Jn 19:21).



  6. The Roman soldiers wanted to be quite sure Jesus was dead. This was to be a quick execution, since Jewish customs did not allow the bodies to be left hanging on a holy day. However, as noted above, they couldn't afford to bungle the operation. They broke the legs of the two thieves, a standard method of accelerating death. Jesus, who we must remember had been flogged prior to his crucifixion, appeared to be dead already: but that wasn't good enough for them: so one of the soldiers stabbed him in the side with his spear, just to make quite sure. This incident is mentioned only in John's gospel, where it is strongly emphasised that this is not hearsay but an eye-witness report (Jn 19:31-5).

    Maybe the release of the fluids by the spear saved his life rather than ended it.

  7. Following Jesus' death, the bodies were not immediately removed from the cross, but were left hanging. Jesus died at about 3pm (Mt 27:45-50, Mk 15:34-7, Lk 23:44-6) yet the bodies were not removed until the evening (Mt 28:57-8, Mk 15:42-6, Lk 23:50-3, Jn 38-42 (this last reference, though not mentioning the time specifically, indicates that Preparation was drawing on and the nearness of the tomb was an important factor, implying it was almost dusk)).



  8. Pilate also wanted to be quite sure Jesus was dead. Mark records that he would not agree to the removal of the body, until after he had summoned the centurion and obtained confirmation that Jesus had been dead for quite some time (Mk 15:42-6).

No conspiracy theory ever advanced has managed to explain how Jesus could have survived this treatment in the face of such clear determination to make sure he was dead. Neither has it been satisfactorily explained how a man who had been subjected to such tortures could be fit enough within three days to convince people that, rather than being a half-dead torture victim he was really the supernaturally resurrected Son of God. Nor why Jesus should be willing to endure such tortures in order to perpetuate a lie, and then vanish without trace within a few weeks, when he could much more easily have simply slipped out of town before he was arrested!

If Jesus secretly went to France after 40 days, as the Albignesians claimed, the only records would be in France.

That is no doubt why both Jewish and Roman authorities are absolutely adamant on this: Jesus Christ was crucified - Finis! Given the facts, there was no way they could possibly deny it.

But if Jesus really did die, all we now have to do to establish the resurrection is to show that he was later seen to be alive. ....

.... Click here to review the Resurrection Accounts.


Or click here to return to Jesus Christ, the History Maker, or on any of the other topics below:


Go to:     Christianity and Christian Resources on the Net   Kevin King's home page.   Kevin's DIY Electronic Postcard   Zetnet home page.


Page creation by Kevin King, e-mail:kevin.king@zetnet.co.uk