ON THE IMPLICATIONS OF GREEN SCEPTICISM

(and much else)

<

The purpose of this diverse collection of articles, lectures, broadcasts, letters to the press and unpublished material, is to place on record a few ideas - located at the intersections of science, philosophy and politics but being by no means the work of an expert in any of these areas - that I have written during the years from 1988 to 1998..

It is not intended that these writings be regarded as in any way final and definitive. They are to be viewed as exercises in 'kite-flying' ..... which more or less like-minded readers may wish to take up, or ignore, or improve upon as they please. The truth is that I think we have not merely a right but a duty ..... to throw ideas into the common pool of tentative wisdom; some may float, some may sink, some may lead somewhere, some may comfort the disturbed, some may disturb the comfortable, some may tell the reader something about the writer but nothing much about the world....

The scope of GREEN SCEPTICISM is wide and rests upon three main ideas: 1) that there is a real basis for concern as to the way we are impinging upon the biosphere; it is quite easy to believe that we may be damaging it more or less severely; 2) that identifying the steps we need to take, and the errors we need to avoid, is often exceedingly difficult and adherence to received wisdom - be it political, religious, scientific or even Green received wisdom - is most unwise and 3) Green endeavour is for everyone and so the principles of democracy in an open plural society are part of the GS package.

It follows that GREEN SCEPTCISM must embrace not only the obvious green questions but also a very wide-ranging critique of almost any department of thought or action and, moreover, a certain mildly satirical approach to received ideas has its place in this website.

I hope that some use can be made of some of this output.

The items listed below are, except for the first few, in roughly chronological order of writing or of publication as the case may be.

ERIC STOCKTON (1924-)

(This is one of the very few graphics items on this list)





GENERAL ITEMS

These are items selected to illustrate the general view upon which all the various items are based.
DOWN WITH GRAPHICS
A sceptical Look at the Internet.
A brief paper read to the Orkney Science Festival September 1996.
THE SCEPTICAL GREEN
Paper questioning green trendiness.
Given to Environmental Concern Orkney March 1996.
ONE HUMANIST'S FAITH
Formal lecture
Given to the Aberdeen Inter-Faith Group April 1997.
ON GREEN MINIMALISM
An analysis of the necessary features of the green outlook - recognising that Greens can be quite a s fallible as anyone else.
This appeared originally in two parts in Atheist Thought Number 19 and Number 20 early in 1998





1988

TOURISM - HOPES AND FEARS
Comment on the hope that tourism can be a satisfactory way of developing a poor economy.
Based on an article in Lady Godiva June 1988.
ON HUMAN FALLIBILITY
Comment of the way high-tech can obscure the fact of human fallibility.
Based on the Editorial in Lady Godiva - July 1988.
MORE ON HUMAN FALLIBILITY
Continued comment on the preceding subject.
August1988.
ON GREEN SELF-HELP
A gentle satire on some of the depths of the Deep Green Tendency .
From the Lady Godiva - December 1988.





1989

QUESTIONS ABOUT SIN and JUDGMENT
Letter to The ORCADIAN : February 1989
A MARKET BASED VIEW OF EDUCATION
Satirical comment not irrelevant to current trends, UK 1998 :
Article in Lady Godiva : March 1989
WHY I AM NOT A CHRISTIAN - 1.
Brief unpublished statement :
Personal letter : March 1989
WHY I AM NOT A CHRISTIAN - 2
Brief unpublished statement :
Personal letter : March 1989
FREE TO CHOOSE
Critical note on 'Choice' :
Article in Lady Godiva : March 1989
DISASTER FUNDS
Compassion or hype? :
Article in Lady Godiva : April 1989
BELIEFS, STATISTICS AND SCHOOL BOARDS
The need to keep Religious Education open :
Letter to The ORCADIAN : May 1989
ON EQUALITY IN RELIGIOUS EDUCATION
Brief humanist comment :
Letter The SCOTSMAN : May 1989
ON HUMANISM AND RELIGIOUS EDUCATION
Fuller account :
Letter The SHETLAND TIMES : May 1989
CREATION - ANOTHER VIEW
Satirical variant of the Genesis story :
Article in Lady Godiva : May 1989
THE TROUBLED KIRK
A brief and not unsympathetic analysis :
Letter to The ORCADIAN : June 1989
SOME CULTURES ARE INFERIOR IN SOME WAYS
A comment on the more naive aspects of multiculturalism :
Letter to New Statesman & New Society - August 1989
ON COMPLACENCY ABOUT NUCLEAR WASTE DISPOSAL
Letter to the Shetland Times - August 1989
OUR FATHER ....
Lateral comment on a hallowed phrase :
Article in Lady Godiva : September 1989
SOME ILLUSIONS ABOUT RADIOACTIVITY
Letter to the Shetland Times - September 1989
DOWN WITH GROWTH
Article in Lady Godiva - October 1989





1990

ON GREEN SENTIMENTALITY
Critique of green fanaticism :
Letter to ECONEWS : April 1990
THE COST & 'COST' OF NUCLEAR POWER
Letter to The Scotsman - April 1990
ON GREEN NAIVETY
Letter to Econews - April 1990
THE SECULAR BASIS OF MORALITY
Greenery is a moral matter and morality does not depend upon religion :
Letter to the New Democrat - April 1990
A SAMPLE OF PIOUS CHUTZPAH
Demolition of a specious Islamic view of the Rushdie affair :
Letter to The INDEPENDENT : May 1990
SECULAR MORALITY
Critique of religious morality :
Letter to NEW DEMOCRAT : July 1990
RADIOACTIVITY - LONG TERM
Scares v. Legitimate Fears :
Letter to The ORCADIAN : October 1990
NUCLEAR POWER - THE SAFETY PARADOX
Letter to The Scotsman - October 1990
POPULATION EXPLOSION
Secular view of it :
Private letter to Prof J P Duguid : October 1990
FACT and BELIEF AS TO FACT
Brief defence of the idea of demonstrable truth :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN : December 1990





1991

A CREDIBLE CREED?
The Bible is the problem :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN February 1991
FRIENDS AND ENEMIES
Critique of "Love your enemies" arising from attitudes to Iraq 1991 :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN : March 1991
KILLING THE DEFENCELESS IS NONE THE BETTER AT A DISTANCE
Comment on the Iraqi defeat in 1991 :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN March 1991
ON DEATH FOR NON-REASONABLE BELIEFS
Martyrdom good? Persecution bad! :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN May 1991
GOD AND UNDESERVED SUFFERING
Brief pointed question :
The ORCADIAN May 1991
BAD THINGS HAPPEN TO GOOD PEOPLE
Critique of 'OMNIGOD' :
Letter to The ORCADIAN May 1991
HUMANIST OPINION AND THE OPINIONS OF HUMANISTS
Draws a significant distinction :
Letter to HUMANIST NEWS June 1991
ON RELIGIOUS EDUCATION
Education in 'Shared Values'
Letter to The ORCADIAN June 1991
PRO-LIFE TURNS INTO ANTI-LIFE
Comment on Population Explosion :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN July1991
ON ABORTION
Against 'Pro Life' :
Letter to The SCOTSMAN July 1991
COMMUNISTS, ATHEISTS and MORALITY
Humanist Ethics vis a vis Authoritarian Ethics :
Letter to The SHETLAND TIMES September 1991
MIRACLES ARE NO BASIS FOR MORALS
LetterThe SHETLAND TIMES Sepember 1991
ON HUMANIST STRATEGY
Lecture to the South Place Ethical Society, Conway Hall, London - September 1991.
A LATERAL LOOK AT POPULIST CHRISTIANITY
A provocative comment on the subject of everyday piety :
Article Lady Godiva December 1991





1992

IS DIALECT DYING?
On the cult of 'Dialect' :
LetterThe NEW SHETLANDER January 1992
: ON RELIGIOUS BROADCASTING
Critique of BBC's Religious Output :
LetterThe Scotsman January 1992
1492 AND ALL THAT
Letter published in the Shetland Times January 1992
WHO IS ACTUALLY 'PRO-ABORTION'?
Comment on a piece of tendentuous terminology :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN : February 1992
RAPE AND THE NINTH COMMANDMENT
A question for Christian traditionalists :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN February 1992
ONE HUMANIST'S VIEW OF THE KIRK
Article by invitation :
Published in LIFE and WORK March 1992
ON TAXATION
LetterThe SCOTSMAN March 1992
APOLOGIA OF AN ANTI-SECTARIAN HUMANIST
Unpublished article April 1992
: EVENTUALLY, TO DROP THE 'ISM'
Article The SCOTTISH HUMANIST May 1992
ON PAPAL INFALLIBILITY
Question to Papists :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN May 1992
ON THE DECLINE OF THE KIRK
Comment on the decline of the Kirk :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN May 1992
ON PRAYER
Critical somewhat satirical comment on 'petitionary prayer ':
LetterThe SHETLAND TIMES June 1992
PRE-MARITAL SEX - a False Inference ?
Critical comment on conventioanl sex morality :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN June 1992
STATEMENTS and OVER-STATEMENTS on NUCLEAR POWER
An attempt to cool the dispute :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN August 1992
MORALITY and the SPELLCHECK
Brief satircal comment :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN October 1992
A NEW HELP-LINE MAY BE USEFUL
Serious question for unbelievers :
LetterThe FREETHINKER October 1992
CAN WE TRUST JESUS
Critcal comment on the usual 'Jesus Story' :
LetterThe FREETHINKER October 1992
IS ECUMENISM a LOST CAUSE
Speech to the Stromness Debating Socciety :
SD Soc. October 1992
AN EXCESS of the LITTLE WOMAN
Satirical comment on a populist writer :
LetterThe HERALD (Glasgow) October 1992
RAPE and the COMMANDMENTS
Comment on the abortion muddle :
LetterThe SCOTSMAN November 1992
IS HUMAN LIFE SACROSANCT ?
Case for Voluntary Euthanasia - briefly :
LetterThe ORCADIAN November 1992
ON FATWA
Very brief demolition job :
LetterThe TIMES (London) November 1992
The SOUTH RONALDSAY CHILD ABUSE STORIES
A sceptical view after the events :
BroadcastBBC Radio Orkney December 1992
ON DOGMATIC SCEPTICISM
An attempt to expose 'scientific' pseudo scepticim :
Unpublished letterLetter The SKEPTIK : December 1992





1993

HUMANISM versus SECTARIANISM
Paper to the 7th Edinburgh Peace Festival - March1993.
GREEN MUST BE FOR REAL
Against to Green Romanticism
Article published in The Freethinker April 1993.
A FAITH TO MOVE MOLEHILLS
Satire on 'non-realist theism' :
Article unpublished June 1993
ON JUST WAR
Brief comment :
Not published June 1993
DON'T BELIEVE IT
Satire on the proposition that 'Religion is a Human Creation' :
ArticleSea of Faith Magazine October 1993





1994

ON PERSNAL AUTONOMY
Wide ranging article :
The FREETHINKER March 1994





1995

VOLUNTARY EUTHANASIA - MY CASE FOR IT
Personal January 1995
HUMANIST AXIOMS
Thoughts on the articles to appear on 'The Plain View' in Humanism Scotland:
Unpublished essay February 1995
MUST WE KILL OTHER ANIMALS ?
A critcal comment on the ethics of vegetarianism and veganism.
Article in Green Scotland May 1995.
AND GOD SAID TO ME. .
A satirical creation myth (May 1995) subsequently published in HUMANIST IN CANADA in Spring 2002
CAN HUMANISM HELP CHRISTIANS?
Common ground of liberal humanism and liberal religion :
Unpublished article June 1995
DO ASTRONOMERS BELIEVE IN GHOSTS?
Sideswipe at simplistic scepticism :
ArticleLady Godiva June 1995
ALCOHOL - A BOON FOR EVER
Based on a student assignment on an aspect of economic self sufficiency.
Article in Green Scotland August 1995.
A NEGLECTED SOURCE OF ENERGY
Human 'horse-power' :
Letter to Green Scotland August 1995.





1996

ON DIRECT ACTION
Article in Green Scotland January 1996.
THIRD WORLD ORKNEY ?
The greening of the Third World is a necessary part of global progress. This article is a brief critical analysis of the changes that have been going on in that world ...... by reference to a First World example nearer home.
Article published in The Shetland News June 1996.
POLITICAL ETHICS IN THE GLOBAL REVOLUTION
Paper to conference on Ethics, Development & Global Values at the Centre for Philosophy, Technology & Society University of Aberdeen - June 1996.
THE ETHICS ATTRIBUTED TO JESUS - A CRITIQUE
'Chapter and Verse' dissected :
Unpublished article August 1996
ON GREEN ASPECTS OF EDUCATION
Article published in Green Scotland Autumn 1996.
ON FOOD FEARS
We need to react with some caution to experts and to scaremongers (who may or may not be the same people).
Article published in The Shetland News October 1996.
THE RISE AND FALL OF JESUS by Steuart Campbell :
Book Review NEW HUMANIST December 1996





1997

RATIONALISM AND EMPIRICISM
Brief comparison and contrast :
Unpublished article January 1997
NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL
Attack on romantic contrast between N and A
Private Letter : April 1997
HUME'S LAW
Claim that the 'naturalisitic fallacy' is not a fallacy :
An unpublished note April 1997 revised in September 1998
CHRISTIAN ETHICS ISN'T SO VERY ETHICAL
Comment on the negative aspects of the Decalogue and the Seven Deadly Sins :
Unpublished article April 1997
ON BEING A PERSON
Analysis of 'Personhood' relevant to 'pro-life' ideas :
Unpublished article April 1997
GREEN CONCERN OR GREEN DELUSION
Article in Green Scotland May 1997.
THE PROBLEM OF GOOD
Brief article - a sideswipe at theodicy :
Article Lady Godiva May 1997
FREE LOVE - WHY NOT?
Critique of conventional morality and of contemporary culture :
Unpublished article August 1997





1998

ON SCIENTIFIC METHODS
Considering that the factual basis of truly Green action can be identified only by proper scienctific inquiry into the way the biosphere actually works, it follows that a sceptical review of Scientific Methods may be of some interest
Letter to a friend February 1998.
AGAINST STATE FUNDING OF RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS
Shared basic moral values - essential for the greening of global society - must be independent of religions; public funds should not be spent on the presumption that morality has to be underwritten by religion .
Letter submitted to the Herald (Glasgow) : February 1998
WHAT'S WRONG WITH BIODEGRADABLE PLASTICS?
Letter from a reader commenting on THE SCEPTICAL GREEN - see above, September 1996.
AGAINST DETESTATION
Critique of secularist fanaticism :
Letter to a friend May 1998
ANOTHER LOOK AT 'MIRACLES'
A critical view of Hume on Miracles :
ArticleNEW HUMANIST Late in1998
NEGATIVE ASPECTS OF CHRISTIANITY
Brief letter to the BHA magazine :
HUMANITY : August 1998
CHRISTIANITY AND HUMANISM
Christianity and Humanism simply compared and contrasted :
LetterPrivate letter to a young freind August 1998
REDUCTIONISM
Article on the use of the term REUCTIONISM by opponents of science/humanism :
Article unpublished August 1998